« Cherry Cobbler - Vegan, Gluten-Free, and Raw! | Main | Are small farms better? »

Is Veganism a religion?

In conversations I've had with people over the years about being vegan, there have been several where people attempt to belittle, or perhaps just reduce my Veganism to just "another religion" or a religious fanaticism like any other. I've thought about this a lot , and have noticed both similarities and dissimilarities with standard religions. I thought I'd run through some, and would love some feedback on the subject.

I am in no way a religious scholar. I was raised Jewish, and was bar-mitzvahed at age 13, but that's it. When I reached adult-hood, I rejected both Judaism and all organized religion in exchange for a direct relationship with God as I understand it to be. As I read more and more on Veganism and the treatment of animals raised for food (dairy and meat), I have found it completely hypocritical for most religions to expound the virtues of compassion, while condoning the torture and suffering of innocent creatures (God's creatures, nonetheless). I mention this only to make the point that since my rejection of any collective religion, I haven't found one even remotely worth joining on that point alone. Unlike religions, Veganism isn't a collective of people searching for meaning, or worth, or the knowledge of what happens to us after we die. Surely there are Vegan groups and organizations (none of which I am a member incidentally), but I believe them to be simply ways of a very small minority of people (last I read, Vegans made up about 1% of the U.S. population) to relate and communicate on something very important to each.

Also, unlike religion, there is no text, ancient or otherwise, that Vegans follow because we believe it to be the "truth." I came to be Vegan because I read many different books (some pro-Vegan, some nutrition, some environmental, some ethical) that lead me to making this decision for myself. I began being Vegan for purely nutritional reasons--I had chronic asthma and carried an inhaler with me. I immediately felt better and have not had asthma since, but it was my subsequent reading of other books besides nutrition-based ones that led me to further solidify my choice and realize the far-reaching effects it has.

There is no doubt that my passion for Veganism bears similarities to religious fanaticism. I admit that freely. But my knowing what is happening to animals as I write this is devastating to me. I make a conscious effort to not force Veganism down people's throats, and the reality is that 99% of my conversations come from questions asked of me when people find out I am Vegan. In other words, I do not, and have never, walked around trying to start conversations with people, but when they start, I am absolutely passionate about what I believe. Do I wish that everyone were Vegan? Absolutely, because the environmental, health, and ethical ramifications would be profound and absolute. I would also argue that daily compassionate decisions such as not brutalizing animals translate into humans treating each other better as well. But I do not want everyone to be Vegan because they will end up in the same place as I after they die, or because they can be a part of my collective, or because they will follow the same rules of behavior set forth in some unified text that a 'higher-up'--a minister, preacher, reverend--has told me is the 'way.'

I guess, in the end, it really makes no difference if Veganism is a religion or not, except that it being perceived as such might turn people away from it. Similarly to religious individuals, I do believe this to be a decision of utmost importance, and would love to engage everyone on this subject. Unlike religions, though, Veganism is supported by research and facts that come from individuals of many different beliefs, many different cultures, many different lands. One thing we share typically though, is that we are profoundly passionate about being Vegan. The earth, and all life on it, is too important for us not to be.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.stanfordinn.com/blog/mt-tb.cgi/28

Comments (2)

Chad:

Is Veganism A religion? I found your post while searching for an answer to that question for quasi-legal reasons. I'm not sure how strict you are, or if you've given vaccines much thought, but I've read that many strict vegans choose to do without them because they usually contain animal products. I'm not a vegan, I am a concerned parent who is against the government mandating vaccines. Here in NJ, school children are MANDATED to get the flu shot. Setting aside any debates on whether it is effective or potentially harmful, (only because I'm ambivalent) my view is that people should have a choice. Currently in NJ, exemptions are only granted for medical or religious reasons. Philosophical objections are flatly denied. My naive view of veganism would categorize it as philosophical lifestyle choice which is currently not protected. I'm hoping that will change. For more info, pls see:
http://www.njvaccinationchoice.org/

Anyway, I'm writing because of your comment:
"I guess, in the end, it really makes no difference if Veganism is a religion or not"
to show that there are reasons why unfortunately it would make a difference.

Just some (Vegan) Food for thought.

Chad:

As a follow up from reading your blog further and searching a few things on the internet, I see similar rules for NC (where I believe you are located at Ft Brag). Only medical and religious exemptions are considered. However I don't think it has been taken as far as NJ has done to make the Flu shot Mandatory.


http://www.vaclib.org/exempt/northcarolina.htm

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on August 4, 2008 3:32 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Cherry Cobbler - Vegan, Gluten-Free, and Raw!.

The next post in this blog is Are small farms better?.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.